Third-episode verdict: Primeval

Posted on February 27, 2007 | 8 comments |

Primeval Carusometer3 Minor Caruso

Primeval has a problem. Okay, it has lots of problems. But its central problem is pacing.

Like a shark swimming along in the ocean, it needs pace. If it slows down, it collapses under the weight of two miles of silliness.

Now the first episode was just fine, nipping along fast enough that you could overlook the masses of plotholes. It was stupid but perfectly acceptable, particularly if you're a kid. The second episode slowed things down a bit, but filled in the gaps with great big giant spiders.

The third episode, though, committed the ultimate crime of being boring: a show about dinosaurs must not, should not be boring.

However, there are other problems. Hannah Spearitt may be 26 and there to appeal to kids, but having her dancing around in her undies is disturbingly close to a widescreen version of Minipops; having her flirt with a lump of man-granite (James Murray) and a student version of Norman Bates (Andrew Lee Potts) is probably illegal in most countries.

Then there's Dougie. Somewhere during the second episode - I probably blinked and missed it - Dougie Henshall must have been shot by a tranquilliser dart, because he's been wandering around with a dazed expression ever since.

This is probably because of the sub-plot with his wife. I'm sure it's supposed to appeal to the adults while the kids snort up the beasties like so much crack cocaine. But we're supposed to believe in a woman who's decided she'd quite like to spend time with dinosaurs back in the past, but doesn't trust her hubbie enough not to bring some of his mates, so fakes her own death instead? Then, after eight years, she gets a bit lonely and asks him if he'd like to come back with her, but instead of turning up at their house, she starts giving messages to his pals when they're close to death along the lines of “Why don't you come back and see me some time – about 80 million years should do it, love, and don't forget the weekly Sainsbury's shop, cos we're going to need plenty of loo rolls.”

All that time by herself and she has, to use one of my wife's expressions, gone doolally tap. No wonder Dougie looks dazed by it all. He's probably calculating precisely how much he's going to have to spend on psychiatric and hospital bills.

I'm not predicting this is going to get any better – in fact, it's probably going to get worse – so I'm probably being generous by declaring that Primeval has earned a three or “Minor Caruso” on The Carusometer quality scale. A three on The Carusometer corresponds to “a show in which David Caruso might guest star. If dinosaurs feature in it, it will be impossible to decide which is more convincing, him or the dinosaurs. Throughout the episode, he will insist on doing a 'cock-a-knee' accent that will make it impossible for any other actors to keep a straight face. He will then storm off set, shouting about how he can't work with amateurs.”

Read other posts about:

8 Comments For This Post

  1. Rullsenberg wrote:
    February 27, 2007 | Reply

    I don't agree but the Carusomater review is STILL hilarious! "Cock-a-knee accent": brilliant.

    And helen Cutter is definitely doolallytap...

  2. Rob Buckley replied to Rullsenberg's comment:
    February 27, 2007 | Reply

    The Carusometer has spoken. Do not argue with The Carusometer or it'll send its agent round.

  3. Stu Nathan wrote:
    February 27, 2007 | Reply

    Its agent has red hair and wears sunglasses, right?

  4. Rob Buckley replied to Stu Nathan's comment:
    February 27, 2007 | Reply

    You should hear his one-liners, too. They're rubbish.

  5. Mark H Wilkinson wrote:
    February 28, 2007 | Reply

    You know, I can think of just the forum on which to mention this review...

  6. Rob Buckley replied to Mark H Wilkinson's comment:
    February 28, 2007 | Reply

    Nooooooooooooooo.....!!!!!

  7. Mark H Wilkinson wrote:
    March 2, 2007 | Reply

    You may have spotted the lack of rabid fangirls baying for your blood; this means I haven't got around to it. And it's a bit late now, anyhow, so you can relax.

    They're probably worse than the Grintologists, mind...

Leave a comment

Your comment
You can use HTML tags for style. To hide a spoiler, put <span class="spoiler"> before it and </span> after it.


Comment preview

Subscribe to comments
You can subscribe by email to any further comments on this entry by checking the box below.

Featured Articles

Life on Mars (US) 1x1

They have their hands on our crown jewels

Read the article

Asides

  • I think TypeKey authentication is working again if you want to give it a try.

  • Don't forget the Strictly Love competition in which you can win a copy of Julia Williams' Strictly Love and Collins' Need to Know? Ballroom Dancing. Deadline for entries is Friday 3rd October.

  • Fringe, episode four: Now that was a good episode. Insane, but good.

RSS feed

Amazon goodies

  • Kingdom of Silver
  • Chocky
  • Strictly Love
  • The Boy That Time Forgot
  • The Vengeance of Morbius
  • The Death Collectors
  • Very Annie Mary
  • Sisters of the Flame
  • The Cazalets
  • Remember Me (Sapphire and Steel)

See all audio play or DVD reviews

Shrine to the blog gods

  • Charlie Brooker
  • Stewart Lee
  • Chris Morris
  • Douglas Camfield
  • Graeme Harper
  • Joanna Page
  • David Tennant
  • Verity Lambert

Find out more about the blog gods