Categorised | Comedy

Review: 30 Greatest Political Comedies

Posted on December 21, 2006 | 7 comments |

Michael Howard and Charles Kennedy

In the UK: Wednesday 20th, 10pm, More4

Aha! The much heralded 30 Greatest Political Comedies! No, really, it was. Okay, I'm lying, it wasn't.

I mean let's face it, if you were the More4 marketing department, would you bust a gut in the run-up to Christmas, promoting a list show voted for by MPs? No. Me, neither. I'd be off with Tiggy, Mimzin and the other PR girls, drinking cosmopolitans at that super new bar that's just opened near Victoria.

So it snuck out last night with the stealth of Jack Bauer, a knife clenched between his teeth, throwing a terrorist's body overboard to cover his tracks. Hosted by two Thunderbirds puppets with uncanny resemblances to Michael Howard and Charles Kennedy, the show listed, surprisingly enough, the 30 political comedies that MPs felt were both the closest to real life and the funniest. Ranging from the election night sketch in Monty Python's Flying Circus to Yes, Minister and The Thick of It, the shows got hyped by various sitting MPs, journalists and broadcasters, strung out on speed and intravenous drug-using Dutch prostitutes.

See? That's what happens when you watch shows about politicians. They rub off on you and you start lying every five seconds.

So what did we learn from the show?

  1. Politicians either have very good memories for shows about politics, with all sorts of lost classics from TV history getting a welcome airing, or they have very good researchers.
  2. Media training counts for nothing, unless its main aim is to turn you into bits of wood or the kinds of monsters who would get chased out of villages by people with burning torches.
  3. Most political journalists are as bad as the politicians. You'd certainly never want to invite Jonathan Dimbleby round to a dinner party to entertain you with his jokes.
  4. Politicians have no taste in TV since they voted The Day Today as number 27 or something. Only if you've never watched The Day Today or you've eaten too much mercury-laced fish will you think that it deserves to be beaten by Mike Yarwood. You fools. All of you.
  5. You can't take Lembit Öpik seriously any more, now he's ditched that nice Sian Lloyd for one of those illegal immigrant Cheeky Girls.

Illuminating, then, but not very different from your standard list show, other than the thin veneer of classiness the More4 branding bestowed upon it and the lack of Chav-U-Like, know-nothing, digital TV presenters filling the talking heads slots. Turns out though, if it's a choice between chav-y, rent-a-quote, eye-pleasing TV presenters and MPs, I'd rather have the first amiable bunch, rather than a load of bitter and twisted power-chasers who are still narked about getting caught out by Chris Morris for Brass Eye.

Hello. I. Am. Charles. Kennedy. I. Am. A. Robot. What. Did. You. Think. Of. That. Michael. Howard. Robot?

Sorry. They're going to be haunting me all day.

Read other posts about:

7 Comments For This Post

  1. Marie wrote:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    Hate to ask, but what won?

  2. Jonathan Reed wrote:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    Probably your funniest post in a long time. You should get your hand bag out more often like that...

  3. Rob Buckley replied to Marie's comment:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    Yes, Minister. It's always Yes, Minister. They loves it, they do.

  4. Rob Buckley replied to Jonathan Reed's comment:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    Ooh, ta very much. I try to be Fair and Balanced?¢‚Äû¬¢ usually, particularly in a public forum like this, even if bad reviews are always funnier than good reviews. After all, even the worst producers, directors and writers have feelings that can be hurt, too.

    But sometimes the urge for ROB TO SMASH takes over. Woe betide the programme that says the magic word and gets 100% of my sarcasmic abilities into full flow.

  5. matt_c wrote:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    Bugger. I meant to record this (what with planning to do a Phd on TV political comedy and all) and then got pissed and played poker. Through your magical connections do you know if (if? I mean when) it will be repeated?

    Should check for torrents too really...

  6. Rob Buckley replied to matt_c's comment:
    December 21, 2006 | Reply

    It's not on any time in the next fortnight, according to the Radio Times. But the thing about list shows is that they're always repeated sooner or later. I'd offer you a copy, but I only recorded half of it.

  7. Rob Buckley replied to matt_c's comment:
    January 2, 2007 | Reply

    I see now that it's on the 6th January at 10.55pm on More4. Set your vid!

Leave a comment

Your comment
You can use HTML tags for style. To hide a spoiler, put <span class="spoiler"> before it and </span> after it.


Comment preview

Subscribe to comments
You can subscribe by email to any further comments on this entry by checking the box below.

Featured Articles

Lost Gems: The Ice House

A ghost story without ghosts

Read the article

Asides

  • Had I been paying proper attention, I'd have noticed that Stephen Moyer, who plays the seemingly friendly vampire in True Blood, also played the seemingly friendly vampire best pal of Jack Davenport in Ultraviolet

  • Don't forget the Sky+ competition. Deadline for entries is Monday 21st July 2008

  • Lab Rats: BBC2, Thursdays, 9.30pm. Laughter count: a few, I guess. Not awful, not bad for a first episode, but needs some work. And it does have both Chris Addison and Geoff McGivern in it.

RSS feed

Amazon goodies

  • Sisters of the Flame
  • The Cazalets
  • Remember Me (Sapphire and Steel)
  • Love Actually
  • Gideon's Daughter
  • Mine All Mine
  • To The Ends Of The Earth
  • Porterhouse Blue
  • The Andromeda Strain - The Mini-Series
  • Gods Behaving Badly

See all audio play or DVD reviews

Shrine to the blog gods

  • Charlie Brooker
  • Stewart Lee
  • Chris Morris
  • Douglas Camfield
  • Graeme Harper
  • Joanna Page
  • David Tennant
  • Verity Lambert

Find out more about the blog gods